Springs

How to tell if garage door spring is broken in an older garage

A loud bang somewhere in the garage, and then the opener runs the next morning but the door barely moves. On a Barrington morning that is often how to tell if garage door spring is broken: a visible gap in a torsion coil above the door, a loose length of spring on an extension setup, or a door the opener cannot lift.

How to tell if a garage door spring is broken: an intact torsion spring pair above a closed door in a Barrington garage.

A torsion spring breaks with a gap in the coil

The torsion spring sits on a horizontal steel shaft directly above the door. When it is working, the coils are packed tight against each other along the full length of the spring. When it breaks, one of those coils opens up, and the spring is now in two separate halves. The gap can be a half inch or a few inches wide, and it is almost always obvious from the floor if the garage light is on.

A torsion spring carries the most tension with the door closed, so a spring can break with the door at rest or as it starts to lift. The sound is a loud bang that can be heard inside the house. On the morning after, the sign is the gap in the spring and a door that will not open on the opener. Both halves of the spring stay on the shaft because the shaft and bearings hold them there; what moved was the stored energy, not the pieces.

Older garages sometimes run on a single torsion spring where a wider door would use two. The median year built for housing in Barrington is 1971.1 A one-spring door with a broken spring looks the same as a two-spring door with one broken side, except the lift is now zero instead of half.

An extension spring hangs loose or is missing

Extension-spring doors use two long coil springs that run along the ceiling, above the horizontal tracks on each side of the opening. A working extension spring is stretched out when the door is closed and shortens as the door is lifted. When one breaks, the sign is a spring hanging loose from one of its hangers, or a spring that is only connected at one end, or on an uncabled door a section of spring you may not see at all.

Older doors are where extension springs most often turn up, and in Barrington an estimated 575 housing units, about 13 percent, were built in 1939 or earlier.2 A broken extension spring with no safety cable through the middle is a reason to keep well away from the door; the pieces may be where they landed, which can be across the garage. Our guide to safety cables covers what a cable is for and why older doors often lack them.

Look at each spring from a safe distance, with the door closed and the opener powered off at the breaker if the door is hanging at an awkward height. A broken extension spring is usually easy to spot: one spring is stretched normally and the other is not, or one end of a spring is dangling.

The door feels dead to the opener

If both of the above are hard to see, the opener will give you a third sign. On a torsion-spring door with a snapped spring, the opener still runs when you press the button, but the door barely rises an inch or two before it stalls or the opener strains and clicks off. Some newer openers show a force-fault flash when this happens. Older openers just stop with the motor straining.

On an extension-spring door, one broken spring lets the door lift crooked, if it lifts at all, lopsided to the broken side. The door is now heavier than the opener was ever meant to lift on that side, because the spring was taking almost all of the weight before and is taking none of it now.

A dead-to-opener door with no spring assist is not a door to keep trying. If the opener runs, the chain or belt will not lift the door, and continued use is how a bent top section or a spring torn out of its hangers happens next. Our emergency repair page covers broken-spring calls when the car is boxed in.

What not to do with either type

A broken spring door is one of the clearest cases where the right next step is to leave the door alone. The following are not DIY, regardless of the reason:

  • Do not lift the door by hand. Without the spring, the full weight of the door is on anyone trying to lift it, and the door can slam closed if hands slip.
  • Do not pull the emergency release. On a hanging door, pulling the release lets the door drop. The hardware is not designed to hold the door at height alone.
  • Do not wind, unwind, loosen or replace any spring, cable, cable drum, bottom bracket or shaft hardware. Everything on that list is under spring tension or is holding it, and injuries from these parts can be severe.

The homeowner steps are visual. Note which spring is broken from a safe distance, what the opener does when the button is pressed, and what you heard and when. Call us with those details.

Reading the three signs together

What you see or hear Likely spring state What it usually needs
Loud bang, gap in a torsion coil, door will not open Broken torsion spring Both springs replaced, cables and drums inspected
One extension spring longer than the other, or one hanging loose Broken extension spring Both springs replaced, safety cables added if missing
Opener runs, door rises an inch or two and stops Broken spring on either type Full inspection, then spring replacement
Opener runs, door lifts crooked and stalls Broken extension spring on one side Both extension springs replaced together
Spring looks fine, door still will not open Not the spring: an opener, cable or track issue A full look at the system; may be a different fix
Door closed and quiet, no bang heard, opener light flashes Often an opener or sensor fault, but a spring break can go unheard Check the springs visually from a safe distance before ruling the spring out

For symptom problems that end up not being a spring at all, our won't open or close page walks through the other causes.

When a tired spring reaches the end of its cycles

A spring is rated for a set number of open and close cycles, which varies by wire size. A door that runs several times a day uses those cycles faster than one that opens once. Our page on garage door springs and the cold season walks through the climate dates at Chicago O'Hare and what a spring call looks like in the long cold stretch here.

When the spring has broken and the car is inside the garage

A broken spring with the car inside leaves the car stuck. The door is heavy without the spring, the opener will not lift it, and the car cannot come out. Trying to force the opener drops the door further and bends what is holding it. Our spring repair page covers how the visit goes, from measuring the broken spring to sizing the replacement.

What a broken spring usually looks like

The common picture is a torsion spring with a clean break near the stationary cone, a two-inch gap in the coil, and both halves still on the shaft. On an extension system it is a spring that has pulled free of its front hanger, with the lift cable hanging slack. On an overnight break, the sound was in the house but did not register as the garage.

The fix is the same shape in each case. Both springs on a two-spring setup are replaced together, since the one that did not break has been through the same cycles as the one that did.

Two halves of a snapped torsion spring with a clean gap between them. That gap is how to tell if garage door spring is broken.

How to tell if garage door spring is broken in Barrington: your questions

Can I open the door by hand if the spring is broken?

Without the spring, the door is at its full weight on anyone who tries to lift it, which on a wood door is a load no one should take alone. The door can also drop fast if hands slip. Leave the door closed and call us.

Will the opener damage itself if I keep pressing the button?

Yes, over time. The opener was sized for a door that the spring was almost lifting on its own. With no spring, the opener is trying to lift the full door weight through a chain or belt that was not sized for that load. The result over several attempts is a stripped gear, a snapped belt, or a bent top section when the door catches on the way up.

What does the cost depend on for a spring replacement?

The number of springs, the wire size and length needed for the door weight and height, whether cables, drums or bearings are being replaced at the same time, and whether an older setup needs safety cables or a torsion conversion. On older garages, the extra parts often matter as much as the springs.

How do I know whether my door has one spring or two?

From a few steps back inside the garage, with the door closed, look up at the header without walking under the shaft. A single torsion spring on the shaft is a one-spring setup. Two springs sitting end to end with a center bracket between them is a two-spring setup. On an extension system, look along the ceiling to each side of the opening; there are almost always two.

Is a broken spring an emergency?

A broken spring is urgent when the car is inside and needed. With the car out and the door closed and left alone, the house is fine until the visit. Either way, do not try to force the door and do not pull the emergency release.

Should both springs be replaced if only one broke?

On a two-spring door, almost always. Both springs went through the same number of open and close cycles, so the one that did not break is near the end of its service too. Replacing both together avoids an uneven lift and a second spring call later.

Walk out of the garage, close the house-side door behind you, and give us the picture over the phone: whether you see a gap in a torsion coil over the door or a loose extension spring along the ceiling, and what the opener did when you pressed the button. Call (847) 534-5389 with that, or leave your number on the callback form and we will call you back.

Something wrong with the garage door?

Describe what you see and hear to someone who repairs garage doors.

Call (847) 534-5389

Mon to Sat 7am to 7pm · Sun 9am to 5pm

Browse all services

Rather we call you?

Leave your name and number and we will call you back.

We use your number only to call you back. Privacy policy